“Firing clients.” Now that’s something that gets a lot of attention these days, in part because it conflicts with the traditional notion of the customer always being right. But experts say some clients are so troublesome and so expensive to serve that you must fire them in order to protect your bottom line, your staff morale, and your own sanity.
What’s more, firing a bad client removes people from your life who sap your energy and motivation, making it harder for you to serve the customers with whom you really enjoy working.
An even bigger reason to fire bad clients is to reduce errors-and-omissions claims. That’s because they are so painful to work with that advisors are tempted to spend less time with them, increasing the likelihood of mistakes and failure to perform required tasks. Both can result in client complaints and lawsuits.
Bad clients exhibit all kinds of irksome behaviors. Some refuse to follow your investment or insurance advice. But then they blame you when their decisions don’t work out. Others have toxic personal habits such as gambling addictions or a self-destructive appetite for market risk. Then there are those who hide information from you (example: off-the-books spending). Finally, some clients simply abuse their advisors—yelling and screaming at them, hurling personal insults, or attacking their racial backgrounds or religious beliefs.
In the face of such nightmares, it’s easy to become unhinged yourself—criticizing “those crazy clients” behind their backs, arguing with them or badmouthing them to others in the community. And if you decide to fire them—we prefer softer terms such as “resigning the account” or “disengaging with clients”—it’s tempting to do it in anger. But this will only breed resentment and result in the terminated client tearing you down on the Internet. Then you’ll pay twice for jettisoning that customer—with lower revenue AND a tarnished professional reputation. Surely, there must be a better way.
Indeed, there is—“conscious uncoupling,” a term popularized by actress Gwyneth Paltrow last year when she announced her divorce from Coldplay rocker Chris Martin. Applied to the challenging tasks of dismissing a bad client, conscious uncoupling implies a mindful, calm, and amicable approach to winding down unproductive and frustrating client relationships. It also suggests an ethical mindset where the advisor expresses concern for the client’s future welfare—and takes steps to assure the client isn’t left in the lurch.
What constitutes a mindful and ethical approach to firing, umm, dismissing a client? Here are the major elements:
First, your decision must be fact-driven, not emotion-driven. Upon a careful review of the client’s account, you must be able to demonstrate that the financial benefit of keeping the client exceed the costs of servicing the client. If the facts don’t support this finding, then you should postpone a decision until they do.
Second, you should make a good faith effort at reconciliation. Always notify clients of your concerns and then give them multiple opportunities to change their behavior. If they fail to, then you are justified in taking action. And don’t forget to leave a paper trail during the remediation process to protect yourself. Remediation should also include an effort to find alternative ways of working together. Perhaps the relationship would work better via e-mail exchanges rather than phone conferences. Or maybe the client would accept a lower level of customer service, presumably at a lower cost to you. The point is, you want to demonstrate your reasonableness and flexibility to the client, even though the person may be utterly lacking in both qualities.
Third, give the person one last chance... in writing. If the problem persists, then begin the dismissal process. Now, having made the decision doesn’t mean you need to execute it immediately, especially if doing so would cause a problem for you or traumatize the client. For example, if the account is very large, you might want to forego the financial hit until you’ve replaced the revenue with new clients. Or maybe the person is facing some life challenges and would be hard-pressed to deal with finding another advisor at the moment. By all means, show flexibility by putting the termination off for a few weeks or months until things calm down.
• Please share your experiences with dismissing trouble clients – or add your tips for handling these types of situations – on this new thread now.
Next page: Steps 4-7
- Small businesses big winner with reinstatement of Health Reimbursement Arrangements
- Insuretech startups Hippo, Lemonade on the attack against agents who sell homeowners coverage in California
- 4 industry trends to watch for in 2017
- Shopping up, enrollment channels shift for Medicare Part D as more consumers rely on brokers
- Why companies can’t get marketing right
- Optimism rebounding among independent P&C agencies; leads to aggressive growth plans in 2017
- Lessons from the U.K.’s bold new retirement initiatives
- Annual review of client needs only makes sense