Trust’s poison pill: Why conflicts of interest are an advisor’s worst medicine
If client trust is the nutrient that builds healthy financial-services careers, then conflicts of interest are the poison that kills them. Financial manufacturers have given lip service to this truism for decades, as have distributors. But the profits that come from conflicts are hard to deny in practice. However, with the fiduciary standard looming on the horizon for securities and insurance producers, advisors will be under greater pressure to better manage their conflicts — or put their careers in jeopardy.
Scare mongering, you say? Then consider these four points:
First, in October 2013, FINRA released its Report on Conflicts of Interest based on a survey of firm and representative conflict-management best practices. The report reviewed three types of systems the industry uses to minimize conflict: enterprise oriented, product manufacturing and distribution driven, and compensation related. Although FINRA said companies and advisors had made progress on all three fronts, it also called on them to do more. It even made a not-so-veiled threat: “If firms make inadequate progress generally,” it said, “FINRA will evaluate whether conflicts-focused rulemaking is necessary to enhance investor protection.”
Second, the SEC announced its enforcement unit will be focusing on conflicts of interest in 2015. According to news reports, the agency will spotlight several key issues, including undisclosed outside business activities and undisclosed bias toward proprietary products and investments. “Only through complete and timely disclosure can advisors, as fiduciaries, discharge their obligation to put their clients’ and investors’ interests ahead of their own,” said Enforcement Asset Management Unit Co-Chief Julie Riewe at an industry event.
Third, the Obama Administration recently gave the Department of Labor the permission to go ahead with rewriting its fiduciary standard for financial advisors involved with ERISA-governed retirement plans. Experts say this will likely have a big impact on commissions paid when clients roll over their 401(k) or other pension assets into an IRA upon retiring or switching jobs. In justifying his decision, the President said that “conflicted advice” generates returns that are about 1 percentage point lower each year. Since IRA assets currently amount to $1.7 trillion, the aggregate annual cost of conflicted advice is roughly $17 billion per year. Although some have disputed this figure, the President’s fiduciary advocacy has put industry conflicts on stark display, increasing pressure on companies and advisors to respond.
Fourth, financial journalists are writing more frequently about the industry’s dueling standards of care (suitability vs. fiduciary) and about how consumers can avoid inherent conflicts in each model. For example, a Wall Street Journal article entitled, “New Financial Advisor? Check Out Fees and Conflicts,” cautions people to probe an advisor’s fiduciary status at the outset. The reporter, Peter Finch, cautioned readers to probe hard for underlying conflicts of interests. For example, he said an advisor might push mortgage refinancing in order to make more funds available for investing, not to save his client money. Or an advisor might recommend a particular brokerage firm for transactions in order to get referrals to new clients.
Are your ready for the new environment?
Put the pieces together and the conclusion is hard to deny. Consumers will soon prefer working with advisors who bring less conflict baggage. And financial professionals will feel greater pressure to become fiduciaries and to be more transparent about their conflicts. Are you ready for this new environment? If not, you’ll have to do two things rather quickly. First, become more aware of the potential conflicts in your business model and second, become more skillful at balancing and disclosing those competing interests.
For example, if you hold a securities license, you’ll need to become more careful about managing the following issues:
• Engaging in outside business activities that give you an incentive to recommend a transaction that benefits you, but hurts your client.
• Offering or accepting a gift or entertainment that colors your business judgment.
• Advising a client to purchase a proprietary or preferred third-party product because your compensation is higher for such products, even though net returns might suffer.
• Pushing mutual funds over individual stocks because you get paid more to sell mutual funds.
• Avoiding index or exchange-traded funds because they pay you less than fully loaded products, even though studies suggest such vehicles are more affordable and tax efficient.
• Selling securities your firm is underwriting to people for whom those securities are unsuitable.
• Favoring equity investments over fixed-income products because product manufacturers generate more fees from the former and are willing to provide higher sales incentives, even though a client’s risk tolerance suggests a need for the latter.
• Giving greater emphasis to a certain product type because you are nearing a compensation-plan threshold that will increase your total payout, again with no consideration of client suitability.
Advisors with insurance licenses
Advisors with insurance licenses face many of the same conflicts, as well as others such as:
• Agreeing to become the designated beneficiary of an insurance policy you sold to a client, even though you have no insurable interest in the person’s life.
• Becoming a collateral assignee of a policy or contract owned by anyone other than a close family member.
• Becoming a trustee of a trust that owns a policy insuring someone other than your close family member.
• Holding power of attorney over a client’s property, especially if it includes a life insurance policy or annuity you sold the person.
• Lending money to a customer or borrowing money from a customer.
Next page: questions to ponder
- Millennials' love/hate relationship with insurance
- Glad you asked: The 5 most important things to know about life insurance
- "Do-It-Yourselfers" not as capable as they think at managing finances
- Carriers using simplified issue to tap into uninsured market
- May's Disability Insurance Awareness Month campaigns focus on younger working adults; small business owners
- 5 reasons to immediately ramp up your efforts to recruit female advisors
- Med Supp market sees 6% growth in 2016 according to new data
- Consumers want simple, transparent life insurance buying options: 2017 Insurance Barometer Study